About this Piece

In addition to continuing to satisfy a large public clamoring for more of his sweet and tender, buoyant and rambunctious songs that could be sung, whistled, and hummed, George Gershwin took another foray into the classics in 1925. This one, the Concerto in F for Piano and Orchestra, was even more ambitious than the previous year’s Rhapsody in Blue: a full-fledged concerto in time-honored three-movement form and a work that was all Gershwin, down to his own orchestration, which had not been the case with Rhapsody in Blue. 

Those who thought Tin Pan Alley’s super-composer had gotten the “serious” bug out of his system with Rhapsody were wrong—in a way. Although the phenomenally talented and successful songwriter turned in earnest to the serious musical forms of concerto, symphonic poem (An American in Paris), and opera (Porgy and Bess), he didn’t change his musical persona for the concert hall—no split personality for Gershwin. Whereas most American composers of his era, many of whom had far more traditional musical training, were writing in the fashionable European styles, Gershwin cultivated his mother tongue—the one truly original American vernacular: jazz. 

It may be true that Gershwin’s style has a highly polished commercial veneer, compared with what is considered real—that is, improvisational—jazz. Still, there is no denying the strength and vitality of the Gershwin product, in whatever form it appears. As for the Concerto in F, it is jazz all the way and a remarkable achievement for a 27-year-old tunesmith. 

The Paris connection was extremely important for Gershwin. His admiration for French music is certainly made tangible in the Concerto’s Adagio second movement. An extended (46-bar) introduction confined almost exclusively to winds and brass (no piano at all) conjures an ambience that goes directly to the heart of Debussy and Ravel. Thematically, the main tune that finally emerges in the piano is hinted at early in the introduction by a muted trumpet. The fascinating manipulations of this theme by piano and orchestra and the figurations and filigree that evolve from it show Gershwin at his most inventive and bracing. The construction of the movement is highly original, with the reappearance of the introduction prefacing a piano cadenza that in turn leads into the “big” tune of the movement—a Gershwin song that is, well, irresistibly Gershwin. The melody is given the grand concerto treatment until it is cut off abruptly for a nostalgic, abbreviated return of the motif from the introduction, this time intriguingly scored for piano and flute. 

The outer movements are, expectedly, fast ones that the composer, in a brief analytical note, described as follows: 

“The first movement employs the Charleston rhythm. It is quick and pulsating, representing the young, enthusiastic spirit of American life. It begins with a rhythmic motif given out by the kettle drums, supported by the other percussion instruments and with a Charleston motif introduced by bassoon, horns, clarinets, and violas. The principal theme is announced by the bassoon. Later a second theme is introduced by the piano. 

“The second movement has a poetic, nocturnal atmosphere which has come to be referred to as the American blues, but in a purer form than that in which they are usually treated. 

“The final movement reverts to the style of the first. It is an orgy of rhythms, starting violently and keeping the same pace throughout.” —Orrin Howard